Skip to Content

Are Pine Needles Good Mulch? (5 Pros & 3 Cons)

Are Pine Needles Good Mulch? (5 Pros & 3 Cons)

Share this post:

This post may contain affiliate links. If you click an affiliate link and make a purchase, I may earn a commission. Also, as an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Whether you’re a seasoned gardener or just starting out, you must have heard about pine needle mulch. Those fine needles that fall from trees and cover your backyard every autumn make excellent organic mulch with plenty of benefits.

But what about their acidity? Will it ruin the soil? Well, pine needles are acidic but not enough to acidify your soil. For many gardeners, the benefits of pine needles far outweigh the cons.

If you’re thinking about making use of pine needles around your garden, read on to further understand the pros and cons of pine needles. Let’s jump in!

Pine Needles Overview

Simply put, pine needles are the leaves of pine trees. They’re usually long, sharp, and thin, but their lengths vary, ranging from 2 to 12 inches.

Pine needles are beneficial for plants, humans, and even animals. For example, they’re a crucial part of the life cycle of pine trees. They help the trees receive the nutrients they need from the sun and act as barriers against pests, diseases, and extremely low or high temperatures.

Regarding animals, pine needles can be a food source for pigs, dear, rabbits, and chickens. For us, pine needles are an organic and sustainable source of mulch.

Pine Needles Acidity

Pine trees usually shed around one-third of their needles from late summer until early winter or late fall. When these delicate and fluffy needles fill your backyard in winter, you wonder if they can make good mulch.

You see many gardeners switch from classic wood mulch to pine needles. On the other hand, others think pine needles are too acidic to be used as mulch.

We did our research, and it turns out the acidity of pine needles is a minor issue that you shouldn’t worry about. Why?

First, pine needles have a pH of around 3.5, which is pretty low, but after they fall, they’re already dead or dying. When pine needles break down, they’re digested by soil microbes, and their pH starts to move toward the neutral range.

What’s more, if you already have a bunch of pine trees next to your garden or backyard, then your soil is already acidic, and adding more pine needles won’t make a huge difference.

Pine needles’ acidity can be beneficial for your plants, especially if you’re growing azaleas, blueberries, or rhododendrons. These plants thrive in acidic soil conditions as they absorb nutrients readily.

However, some plants like roses, asters, boxwood, and lavender aren’t big fans of acidic soil. So if you use pine needle mulch with these plants, keeping an eye on your soil’s pH levels is a good practice to ensure your plants are healthy.

Can Pine Needles Be Used as Mulch? The Pros

Pine needles make ideal mulch for flowerbeds and gardens for various reasons. We debunked the acidity myth earlier, but now let’s focus on other factors that make pine needles suitable for mulching.

1 – Available and Sustainable

If you have a few pine trees around your property, you’re lucky! You have a ready supply of fresh pine needle mulch at your fingertips. All you have to do is to collect those needles in autumn and spread them in your garden.

Unlike using traditional wood mulch, utilizing readily available pine needles is eco-friendly. That’s because wood mulch comes from cutting down tree trunks, which isn’t the case with pine needles as they fall by themselves.

That way, you’re reusing a material that would otherwise be considered yard waste.

2 – Long Lasting

Pine needle mulch decomposes slowly, so you won’t need to change it often. In fact, pine needle mulch last for at least a few years before it needs replenishing. That’s not the case with bark and wood mulches, as they decompose much faster and require regular maintenance.

As pine needle mulch ages, it turns silver, which might add a touch of beauty to your landscape. However, if you don’t like it, you can easily fluff your pine needles in spring to give it a fresh look.

3 – Attractive

For many gardeners, pine needles are attractive and add a touch of beauty and elegance to their landscapes. The rustic and earthy look of those golden-orange needles generally blends well with the green foliage of plants.

Even gardeners who use wood or bark mulch often use artificial dyes to achieve the same color and tone as pine needles.

4 – Good Insulation

Organic pine needle mulch offers decent insulation properties for the soil. Pine needles are light and fluffy and include large air pockets, offering extra protection for the soil against extremely high or low temperatures.

Additionally, pine needles minimize moisture loss from evaporation and protect the soil from weeds.

5 – Soil Protection

Pine needles have an interlocking nature, which helps them stay in place and act as a barrier against soil erosion and compaction.

The Cons of Using Pine Needles as Mulch

Pine needles have been growing in popularity among gardeners for the reasons we mentioned above. However, they still have their fair share of drawbacks.

1 – Not the Best at Controlling Weeds

Remember the air pockets we mentioned earlier? They do a great job of protecting the soil against environmental factors but are not that powerful in weed control.

That’s because they allow moisture, air, and sunlight to get below the mulch, creating a favorable environment for weed seeds to thrive.

2 – Not Appropriate for Use Everywhere

Pine needles aren’t suitable for use in fire-prone areas. That’s because their fine and light texture makes them catch fire instantly and spread around, making wildfires even worse.

3 – Not Suitable in Windy Locations

Pine needles are extremely light and get blown away easily by the wind. So they’re not suitable for use in windy locations.

How to Mulch Pine Needles

Pine needles make efficient and eco-friendly mulch that has several benefits for plants. They’re also easy to use and need minimal time and effort to set up. Here’s how:

  1. Start gathering pine needles from the bottom of nearby pine trees. The best time to collect those needles is in autumn.
  2. Don’t scrape all the needles under the tree because needles protect the trees’ soil.
  3. In case the needles are damp, spread them out in a sunny location and let them dry.
  4. Spread the pine needles around your plants to make a layer of around 2-3 inches.
  5. Make sure you’re using pine needles in a suitable area. You should avoid using them in fire-prone areas as they burn extremely fast and spread around, making the fire worse.
  6. Check your pine needle mulch regularly to see if you need to add more fresh needles. Pine needle mulch last for years, but it’s still a good practice to check it periodically.
  7. If you’re planting plants that prefer alkaline soil, monitor your soil’s pH regularly.

Final Thoughts

Pine needles make excellent mulch for flowerbeds and gardens. They’re lightweight, organic, and long-lasting, so they offer much more than traditional mulches.

As a bonus, pine needles add a woodsy, natural look to your landscape with their vibrant orange-golden color. Even when they age, they turn silver, providing a rustic look that blends well with the rest of your greenery.

Don’t worry about the acidic pH of pine needles. They lose their acidity gradually after they fall from pine trees. So this acidity won’t significantly alter the pH of your soil anyway.


If you want more backyard tips including recipes, how-tos and more, make sure you subscribe to my youtube channel

Share this post: