There are a lot of recipes out there that you can interchange certain ingredients, as long as you know what you are doing. However, this takes a lot of time to perfect, and you have to make sure that you are substituting foods that can be replaced.
Unfortunately, there are times when people confuse two different foods, such as corned beef and brisket, and end up ruining a recipe because he or she thought the two were interchangeable.
When it comes to corned beef and brisket in particular, they are often confused as being similar, even interchangeable in recipes. The only real similarity between the two is the fact that they are both beef.
Their origins are different, the method of making them is different, and the way they are used in recipes are all vastly different. To be able to better distinguish the two, there are a few things that you should know.
First things first, understanding where each dish comes from is going to play a huge role in separating the two of them. Once you know this, you should understand the way each dish is cooked, so that you know why they really aren’t interchangeable.
From here, you should also know what kinds of recipes these meats are used in, simply so that you can remember it for future reference.
Knowing where your food comes from before you cook it is a vital part of understanding how it is used in recipes. It will also help you know, in the future, when corned beef differs so much from brisket, despite being the same type of beef.
If you are interested in grilling or smoking these meats, or you are simply working with a recipe that handles them, you should understand the difference between these two meats.
The Origins of the Dishes
Brisket is, in the eyes of a butcher, a cut of meat. More specifically, it is the lower part of a cow’s chest.
Generally, butchers will cut it a little bit more to make it easier for people at home to work with. It is one of the leaner sections of meat, considering that this is where the bigger muscles of a cow’s chest are.
In a sense, this is the area that supports a large portion of the cow’s weight, which is why it can be such a chewy meat, depending on how it’s cooked, of course.
Corned beef, by technicality, is a type of brisket. It is brisket cut that is corned, which is a method of curing. Corning meat involves using the larger grains of salt (often called corns, hence the name), as well as other spices and sugars to add flavor to the meat.
In a sense, it is a particular type of brisket, flavored in a specific manner. This is one reason why it cannot be used as a substitute for regular brisket.
How Are They Prepared?
Because of its versatility and the fact that it is one of the nine primal cuts of beef, there are many, many different ways that brisket can be prepared.
Some people use it in baking savory dishes, whereas other people will roast the brisket for a traditional southern dish. There are plenty of people who will boil the brisket as well.
Typically, the meat has to be tenderized because of how tough it is, due to its location. In the United States, the most common way to prepare brisket is to smoke it, as well as prepare it with other spices to add a rich flavor to it.
Corned beef, historically, was used in rations during wartime. Ever since then, corned beef has become something that is quick and easy to cook and prepare at home, rather than a meal that takes a considerable amount of time smoking.
This is partially due to the fact that it is already a cured meat instead of a raw cut. Generally, people purchase corned beef in a “ready to eat” format from delis and other butcher shops, but It can be used in other forms as well.
What Kinds of Recipes Are They Used in?
Depending on where in the world you are, brisket can be used in a number of different ways. As mentioned earlier, in the United States it is often smoked for long periods of time alongside other seasonings.
Typically, a specific type of wood is used to add even more flavoring to create an incredibly rich dish. Other than this, people tend to use the burnt ends of brisket as a side dish of its own for its unique texture and flavor.
Brisket is also a common component in pot roasts, both in Britain and in the United States. This involves slow-cooking the brisket in a lidded dish, usually with other ingredients as well as some gravy.
In many other places in the world, brisket is either boiled or braised to make it considerably less tough to chew on. In Thailand, Hong Kong, Korea, and the Philippines, it is a common addition to noodles.
Corned beef, on the other hand, is a lot less world-wide and a lot less versatile. Because of its nature of already being cured meat, there isn’t quite as much that you can do with it, although there are still plenty of unique dishes.
For instance, in North America, corned beef is most commonly used on the Reuben sandwich which also has swiss cheese, sauerkraut, Thousand Island Dressing, and is often on rye bread. People also make corned beef hash for breakfasts, as it can make for a hearty meal.
In other places, it has been a part of cuisine for centuries. For instance, corned beef dates back to the 12th century when talking about Ireland.
There are a number of dishes, both traditional and historical, that used corned beef as an ingredient to sandwiches, although at that time it was considered a rare dish.
More often than not, around the world, corned beef is a canned and common staple that provides basic nutrients in a relatively tasty manner.
What Makes Them Separate?
In the end, corned beef should be considered a type of brisket. It most certainly cannot replace brisket in a recipe due to its cured nature. Brisket, on the other hand, is a specific cut of meat that has a number of uses worldwide.
If you are looking for a versatile cut of meat to use on your next grilled meal, then brisket is certainly one of the ones that you should be considering.
Ben has a bachelor’s degree in construction engineering. When not constructing or remodeling X-Ray Rooms, Cardiovascular Labs, and Pharmacies, you can find him at home with wife and two daughters. Outside of family, He loves grilling and barbequing on his Big Green Egg and Blackstone Griddle, as well as working on projects around the house.
If you want more backyard tips including recipes, how-tos and more, make sure you subscribe to my youtube channel