Skip to Content

A Pizza Stone vs. a Big Green Egg: Which Will Give You That Restaurant Taste?

A Pizza Stone vs. a Big Green Egg: Which Will Give You That Restaurant Taste?

Share this post:

This post may contain affiliate links. If you click an affiliate link and make a purchase, I may earn a commission. Also, as an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Being able to make restaurant-quality pizza right from home is a big benefit of upgrading your appliances. There are options available to you, and it is important to know the difference so you are getting exactly what you want and need.

The Big Green Egg is a dome that you can use to cook a delicious pizza. It is an all-in-one system that quickly heats and cooks pizza to your liking. It is made of durable ceramic that is easy to clean.

You have likely heard of or owned a pizza stone. This is another option that you place your pizza on while cooking it in a conventional oven.

Depending on whether you want a new appliance or an accessory you can use with your current appliances, you will be able to make a great selection between the Big Green Egg and a pizza stone.

When you learn about the benefits of each one, you will be able to make a great decision. Below are the highlights of each one for your comparison.

Big Green Egg Benefits

The Big Green Egg is meant to be used outdoors. It is a multi-faceted appliance that is perfect for making delicious pizza right from home.

With many patented parts and features, you are getting a great product that will give you the longevity you need. Along with its durability comes an appliance with plenty of versatility.

Whether you want to cook at high temperatures or low temperatures, the draft door on the Big Green Egg allows you to fully customize how hot the dome gets. You can heat it quickly for faster cooking, or you can prop the draft door for a slower smolder.

If necessary, you can also use both techniques to give you that perfect crust and baked cheese on top. With a Big Green Egg, the possibilities are essentially endless.

One factor to take into consideration is the Big Green Egg will cost more than a pizza stone. This is because it is an appliance in itself rather than an accessory to use with other appliances.

Because it is meant for outdoor use, this needs to be taken into consideration if you live in a colder climate. When you are cooking in the summertime, the Big Green Egg should meet all of your needs.

When you are not using your Big Green Egg for its oven feature, you can also grill, smoke, and roast with it. This is great for those who enjoy many types of outdoor cooking, especially with meats and other foods that generally take a long time in a conventional oven.

The Big Green Egg is meant to be a lifelong appliance that requires minimal maintenance. As long as you keep it clean, it will stay in great condition.

It also comes with a free lifetime warranty that will protect you if anything happens to your Big Green Egg. There is a lot of support and many helpful resources right on the brand’s website that guide you when you have questions and concerns.

Pizza Stone Benefits

There are many different pizza stones on the market, all relatively inexpensive. It is just as it sounds: a solid piece of ceramic made to heat up evenly and at a higher temperature than your oven provides.

It is shaped perfectly for baking pizzas in your oven. When you use a pizza stone, you are getting that restaurant-quality bake because the dough is being heated intensely from the bottom and throughout the entire pizza.

While it is meant to be used indoors, it is still versatile in the sense you can easily remove and clean it when you are done using it. Pizza stones absorb heat very easily, so you will want to make sure that it is fully cooled down before you handle it.

Most pizza stones are small enough to be stored conveniently with your other appliance accessories. Even if your oven is on the smaller side, there should be a pizza stone that is compatible.

Unlike the Big Green Egg, the pizza stone only costs a fraction of the price because it is not an actual appliance. It is also available in any cooking store or home goods store near you.

This convenience makes for a big benefit and is why a lot of people choose to go with this option. Convenience is the key to making your cooking experiences positive and productive.

You will not have to worry about regularly maintaining it, only thinking about general upkeep such as cleaning. If anything happens to your pizza stone, you will likely just buy a replacement since they are relatively inexpensive.

Even though you will not have a lifetime warranty, this should not be an issue if you know how to properly use and clean your pizza stone. There are many resources available online, and it is likely that someone at your local cooking store can give you some additional tips.

Pizza stones are more well known than the Big Green Egg, so there is more information out there to help you learn how to use one. This is great for home cooking at all levels, especially for beginners.

A Comparative Review

Now that you can see the side-by-side differences, there is probably one option that stands out more than the other. No matter which one you choose, you will be able to make excellent pizza right from home.

The Big Green Egg is great for those who have a little more experience with cooking. It is an outdoor appliance with many features and a lot of versatility.

A pizza stone is suitable for anyone who is looking to add a new kitchen accessory into their home. Since it is just a single slab of ceramic, there is not much that you will need to learn about it before you start using it to cook your pizzas.

If you feel as though you do not want to choose just one, you can always start off with a pizza stone to see how you like it. This is the more budget-friendly and simpler option.

Once you become comfortable with this, you might decide on purchasing a Big Green Egg for outdoor use. The great thing is that both are excellent for achieving the perfect bake on any pizza.

Think about this decision before you make a purchase, and you will definitely be happy with your results. There are so many ways to cook pizza from home, and both a pizza stone and the Big Green Egg will definitely enhance this experience for you.

Both are great because they amp up the flavors of your pizzas. Instead of only using a conventional oven, you will be using a product that heats more evenly and gives a restaurant-quality taste to your food.

After taking a look at all of the features, you should be able to make a decision that best suits your needs. If anything changes or if you simply want to try something new, you can eventually incorporate both into your home-cooking routine.

Experiment with different methods because this is part of the fun of making pizza! You will soon enjoy cooking even more than you already do.


If you want more backyard tips including recipes, how-tos and more, make sure you subscribe to my youtube channel

Share this post: